transit

Chicago Elevated: unique, simple and complex

After three weeks I continue to be fascinated by the Chicago L system. The downtown area is known as "The Loop" because all of the trains* meet there. And while it's not unusual for a large old city to have a radial rail system, what is unique is that four of the six main lines circle the downtown on an elevated alignment known as The Loop. This type of infrastructure existed in most large American cities a century ago but remains in only a handful of places, with Chicago probably being the only city with elevated tracks still operating downtown (although some cities are building new elevated light rail lines). The Loop is a work of art but also a minor operational miracle. Each side of the rectangle has only two tracks with closely spaced stations. The CTA Green Line serves only two sides as it travels both west and south, while the Pink, Orange & Brown Lines (and the Purple Line in rush hours) use the Loop to turn around before returning to their other terminus.

The other lines (Red, Blue) pass under the Loop in two parallel subway tunnels and passengers can make the long vertical trip to transfer at Jackson or Lake.

This picture (courtesy of Chicago L user Graham Garfield) shows Green or Pink Line train entering the Loop at its northwest junction by traveling eastbound on Lake Street.  In typical operation, trains approach the junction, wait for a signal, then cross oncoming traffic just like a car making a left turn on the street below. There is no space to layover and nowhere to pass a disable train, so a delay or broken switch can be a nightmare. Sometimes trains are sent around the loop a second time if an open drawbridge ahead prevents a train from exiting here.

When I say that just getting the buses and trains back to the garage at the end of the day is a feat in itself, this is the kind of stuff I'm talking.  However, it's really cool looking into the buildings and out over the city when the turns makes its very tight turns.

* For this post I mean only rapid transit (subway/metro) trains.  Because the transit systems were built be competing companies, as in most large cities, the regional rail and bus stations are located a short walk from the Loop.  Also for the same reason, there are 12 regional rail lines operating from four different terminals, and intercity buses stop at a different terminal.

P. S.  Have you been following me on Facebook and Twitter?  Read my micro thoughts and some of my favorite of micro transport posts/tweets by others.

Episode 22: Transitized: Chicago transit, bikes, pedicabs

I sat down with Shaun Jacobsen, Chicago resident and author of the local blog, Transitized.  We learn about the city's transit system which consists mostly of elevated trains, a comprehensive network of slow buses running in mixed traffic, and an infant bike network consisting mostly of sharrows and "weasel lanes". Shaun explains how to redesign our streets for people and tells us where to find the money we're always told we don't have (hint: stop expanding highways and subsidizing car parking). Minku Sharma of the Vegan Pedicab Podcast is back in the second half to talk more about transit, street design and our pedicab experiences (including the big tire blowout).

IMAG0187

This week's music is provided by the Weakerthans from Winnipeg.

Visit criticaltransit.com to find out more, follow the blog, make a donation or sponsor an episode to support this work and my ongoing Sustainable Transport Tour.  Spread the word and follow my work on facebook and twitter.  Please contact me if I may be passing through your city, or if you have suggestions on places to go or people to meet.

Transit & Chicago's United Center

Last night I visited the United Center -- home arena for the Chicago Blackhawks hockey team, Bulls basketball team and many concerts -- for the first time. While I was mainly there to drive a pedicab, I did take note of the transportation network as I am known to do. What struck me most about the United Center is its poor access to transportation facilities. It is located two miles west of downtown and surrounded by giant parking lots (the grey areas on the map).

Map-United-Center Even though it was built only 20 years ago, in one of the largest cities in North America, no provision was made for a rapid transit connection. The closest station is Illinois Medical District on the Blue Line but that's a pedestrian unfriendly 15 minute walk (from parking lots to an expressway median). The Pink Line travels within two blocks of the stadium but does not stop nearby.

The CTA runs a bus shuttle before and after the game -- Route 19, United Center Express -- to the downtown area for rapid transit and regional transportation connections. Yesterday there were four articulated buses staged to load as the game ended. That's a capacity of only 400 people. What about the rest of the 20,000 attendees?

CTA_Route19_UnitedCtrExp

It seems that, as a direct result of this built environment, most of them drive. There is no incentive to visit anything nearby and thus no disincentive to driving. In fact, both of the pedicab rides I got after the game were to nearby parking lots.

The developer of the stadium should have been required to build a Pink Line station on Madison Street, make pedestrian improvements on the route to the Blue Line, and pay for increased service before and after the game. I don't know if they pay for the bus shuttle but experience elsewhere suggests it's unlikely. The Prudential Center in Newark, NJ is an example of a stadium built recently with no parking facilities and funding for transit service.

Down with the slush puddles

It's been a weird week. My former host cities in the northeast are seeing record snowfall and all I have here in the midwest in a bunch of slush. We tend to this of snow mounds, slush puddles and ice and necessary evils, but they don't have to be. It's only because we live in a society where cars come first and everyone else is an afterthought if even a thought at all. Notice how the street is completely clear but puddle and uncleared slippery sidewalk makes pedestrian facilities unavailable.

IMAG0015

Slush (and rain) puddles can be essentially eliminated by raising the street up to the sidewalk level instead of ramping the curb down to the motor vehicle area. The rest of the hazards can be eliminated by expanding public snow clearing responsibilities to include public walkways. The current arrangement wherein we expect property owners to maintain abutting walkways causes snow to be dealt with in a haphazard fashion, unevenly and unpredictably, with some places being clear and others becoming a skating rink. I love to play hockey, just not on my way to the bus. Rarely do you see an entire street block cleared. It would be so much more efficient and effective if the city just drove a narrow snow plow down the sidewalk, for a miniscule fraction of the current auto-only snow clearing budget. Such a system would also motivate us to spend a summer fixing all the broken sidewalks so we could easily plow them.

Again, we send a very clear message by plowing the way for cars preemptively or within hours yet leaving everyone else to risk injury on hazardous walkways.

Episode 20: Urban Rail Exploration with Adham Fisher

If you like riding transit as much as I do, you will enjoy my conversation with Adham Fisher, who travels to different cities to attempt record journey times on rapid transit systems. Adham held the Chicago L record until last year. He has also been to New York, TorontoLondon, Newcastle, Paris and Barcelona, and tried his luck on the UK regional rail network. Follow Adham on Twitter @DirectionTravel. AdhamFisher_Chicago

This episode was put together on the Lake Shore Limited train. I am now in Chicago covering the local and regional transportation network and beginning my sustainable transport tour. More info on that in the coming days.

Episode 19: Time's Up bike activism, driving a pedicab, and the big tour announcement

After a brief recap of my experience driving a pedicab in Washington, DC during the presidential inauguration, I stopped by the Time's Up bike coop in Brooklyn to chat with Keegan about how bike activists can create the change we want to see in the city. Time's Up is an all-volunteer grassroots direct action environmental organization working to ensure access to safe, sustainable, affordable transportation for everyone. Get involved with Time's Up by joining rides, fixing bikes, and helping and networking with other activists in the broader struggle for social and economic justice. Learn more about bicycles, rickshaws and social justice from the Vegan Pedicab Podcast.

Lastly, an exciting announcement about the future of the show as a component of my sustainable transport tour.  The next stop is Chicago.  Please get in touch if you have anything to share with readers and listeners, and consider supporting my upcoming fundraising campaign if you like the idea and enjoy learning about sustainable transportation.

Episode 17: conversation in transit with Brock Dittus from The Sprocket Podcast, regional connections

I hopped on a train from Boston to Providence last week with Brock Dittus from The Sprocket Podcast. On the return train we got out the microphones and had an interesting chat about bikes, buses, trains, slow travel between cities, suburban sprawl and much more. Brock mentioned Tri-Met of Portland, the Lower Columbia Community Action Project which provides limited rural transit service in Washington state on a shoestring budget, and Transportland cargo bikes. Thanks to Josh Zisson from Bike Safe Boston for loaning Brock a superb single-speed bicycle.

At the end of the show I share an experience where a connection between LRTA and MBTA was practically useless due to lack of information. A great example of an inter-agency regional transit connection is the Coastal Link operated jointly by Bridgeport, Milford and Norwalk transit agencies on the Connecticut shore line. This decade-old route fills a gap in a retail-oriented suburban area and is part of a a series of local bus routes running from the New York line to the Rhode Island line.

 

Episode 16: Livable Streets with Charlie Denison

While in Boston I sat down with Charlie Denison, Advocacy Committee Chair of the Livable Streets Alliance, a local network of sustainable transportation advocates. We discuss the latest in the ongoing effort to redesign our transport networks to serve all users and shift the balance away from car oriented development. Charlie is a multimodal transit user and passionate advocate for safer and more inviting streets where everyone can coexist peacefully. Find out more about the Livable Streets Alliance and read Charlie's blog on the Somerville Patch.

Articulated subway trains

The new subway cars in Toronto have an excellent feature that I wish all transit agencies would adopt. The "open gangway" means that the cars are connected to each other in an articulated train set with a section similar to the middle "accordion" section of light rail cars and long buses. The ability to walk easily between cars increases capacity by allowing crowds to disperse throughout the train. It also improves safety as you can see through the entire train and won't be isolated, and nobody can become injured when trying to pass between cars on a typical subway train. This setup is apparently common on trains in Europe but not in North America.

The main disadvantage of having the cars permanently connected is that an entire train set must be removed from service when maintenance is needed, so you need more cars in your fleet.  With a typical setup, one or two cars can be removed and the rest coupled with other cars ready to carry passengers.  I think it's worth spending a little more money to get the benefits of articulated train sets.  Although I guess it would also be bad if you can't change cars to escape the guy who hasn't showered in weeks.

Episode 15: Scheduling, construction, privatization, service quality, how to not get hit by trains

News items fill up this week's show. More cities trying to speed up construction projects by shutting down line segments. Bus rapid transit lines often promote themselves based on the inclusion of things that should be standard on all buses. Privatization is usually bad policy. I discuss the impacts of scheduling on operator health and system safety. Finally, I explain how to help someone who falls on the train tracks (hint to NY Post: put down your camera and go get help.) Chicago: CTA Red Line South Renewal Project

Long Island, NY: Privatized NICE bus ridership decline & LI Bus Riders Union

Palm Beach, FL: Lack of bathroom breaks for drivers

San Antonio, TX: Via Metropolitan Transit launches Via Primo BRT route (article)

Vancouver, BC: TransLink launches Compass Card for contactless fare payment

Washington, DC: WMATA studying operator fatigue

New York City: Jerk takes photo of man being hit by train instead of trying to help

Sacramento, CA: General Manager rides the bus (a novel concept!)